Click to go to American Public Media's home page. Click to go to Speaking of Faith's home page. Speaking of Faith E-mail Newsletter
Click image to visit the Web site for Muslim Women and Other Misunderstandings.
Click here to forward this e-mail to a friend! Krista's Journal: October 14, 2005

Online Exclusives
Complete Transcript
Read the complete transcript from last week's program, "The Soul in Depression," featuring guests: author Andrew Solomon, Quaker author and educator Parker Palmer, and poet and psychologist Anita Barrows.

Exlusive Audio
Not on the Radio

Listen to Parker Palmer elaborate on his approach to depression and the role of community in healing.

Upcoming Shows
Evangelicals out of the Box
Stereotypes tell us this: Evangelical Christians are politically conservative, closed-minded, morally judgmental, and anti-science. Our two guests , Jamie Meyer and Nancey Murphy, defy such generalizations. They want to open American imaginations about who Evangelicals are, what motivates them, and what they might do in the future. They're critical of journalism about evangelicals and of the Evangelical movement itself.

GIVE TODAY!
Your tax-deductible contribution helps support Speaking of Faith's many services, including free streaming audio and Web exclusives.

About Speaking of Faith
Hosted by Krista Tippett, the public radio program is heard weekly on radio stations around the country, bringing a wide range of intelligent religious ideas and voices into American life.

Contact Us
We'd love to hear your comments or suggestions about the e-mail newsletter and our Web site. Let us know how we're doing!



This week on public radio's national conversation about belief, meaning, ethics, and ideas:

Muslim Women and Other Misunderstandings
[Web Site ¦ Listen Online]

Is there such a thing as the Muslim world? Is the "veil" a sign of submission or courage? Is our Western concern about women in Islam really a concern for the well-being of women? This week's guest, Egyptian-American writer and scholar Leila Ahmed of Harvard, challenges current thought on these and other questions.

Asking Myself New Questions

Speaking of Faith host Krista Tippett
Recently President Bush's envoy Karen Hughes made a "listening tour" of Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Turkey. She heard again and again from women in her audiences that they don't appreciate American analyses of what is wrong with Muslim women's lives. They ranged from angry to bemused. Hughes was not representing a Republican point of view, I think, but common western and even feminist assumptions. And as Leila Ahmed helped me understand, these are misperceptions that we have in common with a long line of others before us.

The root of the problem, she says, is our fixation on clothing and headdress as a root symbol of subjugation and misery. "Wearing the veil" is a practice that early Muslims took from the Jewish and Christian and Zoroastrian cultures around them, and it was long a sign of social class rather than religious devotion. In Islamic cultures, as we rarely pause to notice, covering one's head is an expression of modesty and piety followed by men as well as women. In the sophisticated upper classes of the Egypt in which Leila Ahmed grew up, neither she nor most of the women in her family wore the veil. She admits that, like western feminists, she long imagined it as a trapping of a less enlightened past. However, she's watched the meaning of the veil change dramatically in her lifetime in Egypt as well as among younger Muslim women in America. As she sought to understand this, she challenged her own inherited assumptions and found them wanting. She spends a great deal of this hour provocatively challenging mine.

Most critically, she challenges me to examine the deeper judgments that lurk beneath our culture's "concern" for Muslim women. We interpret "the veil" not merely — or even principally, Ahmed suspects — as a sign of what ails Muslim women. It seems rather to reinforce prejudices we hold about the inferiority of Muslim tradition as a whole. In her ground-breaking work, Women and Gender in Islam: Historial Roots of a Modern Debate, Ahmed explores the long story of westerners' inclination to interpret the veil as a proof of an innate backwardness in Islam. Her fascinating chapter, "The Dialogue of the Veil," is on our Web site. Contemporary American ideas and attitudes hearken backwards, it turns out, to the foibles of the British Empire before us.

Leila Ahmed worries less about the veil than about the breakdown of extended families in Islamic societies. She worries less about the fact that Islamic women tend to lead lives relatively separate from men's lives, that is, than that women in modern societies are less able to support each other in practical and robust ways. She worries about the poverty of so many Muslim women, which hinders them in all the ways poverty hinders any human being. It restricts their freedom and education and leaves them susceptible to teachers who come from the outside proclaiming a rigid and patriarchal religion as the only true orthodoxy. And if someone asked me what general concerns I hold for American women, as Leila Ahmed does in the course of this hour, my answers must echo hers.

On this and other points, Leila Ahmed turns my questions back on me — gracefully and provocatively and effectively. One by one, her questions compel me to examine my instincts and reframe my way of seeing "the Muslim world."

Egypt and other majority Islamic countries have grown more religiously active and conservative in recent years, she concedes. But so, she insists, has her adopted country, America. Do we only worry about Islamic women when this happens? And what do we Americans mean when we refer often and broadly to "the Muslim world"? Where does "the Muslim world" begin and end these days? Its borders are impossible to draw, and arguably must now encompass Paris or Amsterdam or Chicago. Conflating the notion of "the Muslim world" with "the Arab world" only compounds our inability to make important distinctions about the global reality we inhabit.

There are many other ideas and insights in this program, but most of all Leila Ahmed leaves me with new questions. I have not been able to think about Islam or read the news in the same way since I spoke with her. If education is in large part about asking good questions, as I discerned early in my life, this is one of the most educational hours of radio I've been privileged to produce.

A Border Passage: From Cairo to America--A Woman's Journey by Leila Ahmed
Krista Recommends Reading:
A Border Passage: From Cairo to America—A Woman's Journey
by Leila Ahmed

Ahmed is the author of a powerful memoir, A Border Passage: From Cairo to America—A Woman's Journey; and an original scholarly work, Women and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate. She is a lyrical and lucid thinker and writer, exploring history — both personal and public — as a critical resource for understanding contemporary experience. In addition to telling a riveting story in beautiful prose, her memoir is an extended reflection on how the world changes around us, and how our perceptions even of our own histories are impressionable, not factual and fixed. In a sense, her scholarly work yields to the same insight, offering up facts, stories, and ideas that are nuanced and ultimately empowering.



This message contains graphics. If you do not see the graphics, go to http://speakingoffaith.org/programs/muslimwomen/emailnewsletter.html.